
The U.S. Department of Education has launched investigations into several teacher preparation programs, alleging discrimination based on race and sex. The investigations target programs aimed at recruiting historically underrepresented groups in the teaching profession, such as men and teachers of color.
The Office for Civil Rights is scrutinizing programs that prioritize recruiting and training candidates from underrepresented groups, such as men and teachers of color. This marks a shift in the department’s approach, using civil rights protections to challenge diversification efforts.
Programs Under Investigation
Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights Kimberly Richey stated that race, national origin, or sex should not decide who will shape America’s next generation, yet many states and universities seem to prioritize recruiting and training ‘minority’ candidates rather than evaluating candidates based solely on merit.
EdTrust, a nonprofit advocating for racial and economic equity in education, criticized the investigations. They argue that using civil rights protections to undermine diversification efforts betrays the purpose of these laws.
Eric Duncan, director of Pre-K-12 policy at EdTrust, stated that the administration’s divide between ‘merit’ and diversity perpetuates the idea that teachers of color are less qualified. He emphasized that scholarships addressing systemic barriers are essential to ensuring family wealth does not determine who can become a teacher.
Institutional Response and Impact
The City University of New York defended its NYC Men Teach Program, stating it is open to all students regardless of race, gender, or national origin. Established in 2015, the program has contributed over 3,100 new male teachers of color to New York City Public Schools.
The American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education highlighted the importance of a diverse educator workforce in addressing teacher shortages and ensuring student access to well-prepared teachers. However, they declined to comment on the specific investigations.
These investigations are part of a broader effort by the Trump administration, following the 2023 Supreme Court ruling in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard. The administration has terminated federal grants and issued directives to review grant awards for discriminatory practices.
The loss of over 100 federal teacher training grants caused at least 127 teacher candidates to drop out of their programs and another 259 accepted candidates to not enroll after all. The Justice Department has also warned districts about potential legal liability in their recruitment practices.
Broader Implications and Legal Context
In 2025, the administration terminated federal grants under programs like the Supporting Effective Educator Development Grant Program, the Teacher Quality Partnership Program, and the Teacher and School Leader Incentive Program. The Department of Education admitted in a March court filing that it had canceled 104 out of 109 active grants under these programs, citing the promotion of “divisive ideologies.”
The directive required agency personnel to review all new and issued grants to ensure federal funds did not support “discriminatory practices,” including those related to DEI. The directive added that “Illegal DEI policies and practices can violate both the letter and purpose of Federal civil rights law and conflict with the Department’s policy of prioritizing merit, fairness, and excellence in education.”
Legal Warnings and Future Concerns
This included asking job applicants about their cultural background, using recruitment strategies targeting specific geographic or racial groups, and inquiring about how candidates overcame obstacles.
Since the Supreme Court’s decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, civil rights groups have raised concerns that it would set back educational equity efforts even outside of race-conscious admissions. Scholarship availability, teacher pipelines, and student affinity groups are among the areas advocates fear could be affected.